Toast, which chain is the future chain you refer to? Final btsx chain?
There will be *many* X chains. At least one of them will have 50/50 without dilution.
what is this suppose to mean? We need a clear and official clarification of this.
Does this stickied topic help?
https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=2940.0
that topic is exactly what I believe it should be. see the fourth paragraph:
If our goal is to see the value of BitShares XT to grow then we need to future-proof peoples investment in BitShares XT after launch against being devalued by one of our planned upgrades or the flood of variants with different assets. For this reason we have decided to recommend that all future chains based upon the concept behind BitShares X be initialized with a snapshot (100%) of the state of BitShares XT around the time of their launch. Thus the primary vehicle for investing in future BitShares X chains will be to own BitShares XT.... likewise, chains that are variants of BitShares XI or XV should honor their parent with 100% stake.
if they are all 100%, how come "At least one of them will have 50/50 without dilution."
All we can do is recommend what
appears to be best at any point in time. As better ideas are developed, they may be more promising (more likely to succeed in the marketplace). So, if they are perceived to be better,
somebody will release them and then the market will decide.
This leaves III with the choice of updating our recommendations to take into account new innovations, or denying the value of those innovations and having our recommendations become increasingly irrelevant.
The 10 Natural Laws of the Crypto Universe dictate that the first BTSX DAC (50/50 without dilution) will be cloned (by somebody) to give it new competitive advantages as soon as they are invented.
One such competitive advantage is likely to be a highly motivated group of trusted celebrity delegates with a talent for promoting themselves and the industry - competing for the right to represent the community and working hard to bring in new stakeholders to vote for them. Someone will surely release something like it, regardless of what we do or say.
Another competitive advantage might be a variant that teams 50/50 with some other big community - who knows? Will you cling to the first release of BTSX if DogeShares heads for the moon? You will own both and have to decide whether to keep or sell each of them.
It is our duty to recommend to you the most competitive solution we know of at any point in time. Everyone can take that into account in making their own personal investment decisions. Fragmentation will happen, but will be reduced by having III put its weight behind what we believe is the best of the best. If we fail to do that, our credibility will slip and so will our ability to mitigate fragmentation.
We produce a toolkit that developers/operators can use to release all kinds of variants. To succeed, there needs to be a developer/operator who believes in one particular combination of parameters enough to release it and continue to support it - and there needs to be a marketplace that will embrace that solution above all others.
Your role in this forum is to convince would-be developers/operators that there is a demand for a particular instantiation of the general-purpose toolkit we are developing for you.
Argue the merits.