BitShares Forum

Main => General Discussion => Topic started by: freedom on February 29, 2016, 01:31:23 pm

Title: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: freedom on February 29, 2016, 01:31:23 pm
I create an asset but how to withdraw bts(2500) from feepool?
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: svk on February 29, 2016, 01:45:33 pm
I create an asset but how to withdraw bts(2500) from feepool?

You can't withdraw directly from the fee pool.

What you can do however is claim the fees earned by your asset when people do trades with it or pay their fees using it. You'll find that in Update Asset > Fee pool tab, at the bottom under "Claim asset fees".
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: JonnyB on February 29, 2016, 01:46:49 pm
I've been wondering this to but I don't think it's possible.
let me know if you find out.

Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: abit on February 29, 2016, 04:48:10 pm
I've been wondering this to but I don't think it's possible.
let me know if you find out.
Take a look at what asshole1 did with PERCENT asset.
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: tonyk on February 29, 2016, 06:53:35 pm
@abit @JonnyBitcoin @svk

Actually here is how is this done... smoothly. Courtesy of sports-owner. Pay attention to the fee.

1.
http://cryptofresh.com/tx/82ed3de6a98c6cf8a5cdf69afd956bdfa0eb2331 -> Show raw transaction
2.
 then cancel.
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: abit on February 29, 2016, 06:57:55 pm
@abit @JonnyBitcoin @svk

Actually here is how is this done... smoothly. Courtesy of sports-owner. Pay attention to the fee.

1.
http://cryptofresh.com/tx/82ed3de6a98c6cf8a5cdf69afd956bdfa0eb2331 -> Show raw transaction
2.
 then cancel.
Yes that's it.
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: cube on March 01, 2016, 03:03:00 am
@abit @JonnyBitcoin @svk

Actually here is how is this done... smoothly. Courtesy of sports-owner. Pay attention to the fee.

1.
http://cryptofresh.com/tx/82ed3de6a98c6cf8a5cdf69afd956bdfa0eb2331 -> Show raw transaction
2.
 then cancel.
Yes that's it.

Is there a proper withdrawal function being planned/in the pipeline?
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: tonyk on March 01, 2016, 06:53:41 am
@abit @JonnyBitcoin @svk

Actually here is how is this done... smoothly. Courtesy of sports-owner. Pay attention to the fee.

1.
http://cryptofresh.com/tx/82ed3de6a98c6cf8a5cdf69afd956bdfa0eb2331 -> Show raw transaction
2.
 then cancel.
Yes that's it.

Is there a proper withdrawal function being planned/in the pipeline?

Why? What is wrong with this one?

It is working... at least

very much unlike:

-my win witness_node

-my Ubuntu witness_node

-my  Ubuntu light client

-my Ubuntu Chrome wallet

Should I post a link for each and every not working feature...again?
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: abit on March 01, 2016, 09:53:32 am
@abit @JonnyBitcoin @svk

Actually here is how is this done... smoothly. Courtesy of sports-owner. Pay attention to the fee.

1.
http://cryptofresh.com/tx/82ed3de6a98c6cf8a5cdf69afd956bdfa0eb2331 -> Show raw transaction
2.
 then cancel.
Yes that's it.

Is there a proper withdrawal function being planned/in the pipeline?
Why not just don't put half of asset creation fee to the fee pool by default? The fee pool is designed to give conveniences to some of asset issuers, but apparently some other issues don't like/need that convenience. In addition, the fee pool is a bit vulnerable if the issuer doesn't use it in the right way.
Title: Re: I create an asset but how to withdraw bts from feepool?
Post by: destenson on April 21, 2016, 03:18:16 am
I think that exploiting the fact that trade fees are taken in one asset and returned in another is a terrible way to handle this. In fact, that particularly exploitable "feature" should either be removed, or made an optional permission/flag for asset creation. Instead fees should be returned in the same form as they were taken by default. And if an issuer wants to withdraw from the fee pool, that should be made an optional permission/flag on the asset as well.