BitShares Forum
Main => General Discussion => Topic started by: Geneko on May 28, 2017, 02:38:01 pm
-
There isn't any thread that tracks such event. If there is any pls point out and remove this one.
Poloniex have simply disabled withdrawals of BTS because they cant disabled deposits on their Bitshares account..
There isn't any related information about that on their notices section. Only on deposit and withdrawals page. Which means hidden for majority of interested parties. Is this for everybody or this might be selective? This doesn't have to do anything with daily limit I am sure.
This is nothing new on Polo these days, I have read about many complains for other currencies too, but I was wondering why there isn't any thread that informs and tracks of such behavior for BTS. This is not benevolent, such behavior might be used for price manipulation (BTC withdrawals enabled) or indicate something much more serious.
If we could be regularly informed about such behavior it might help understand the back end story...
-
the crux of the story is: do not use centralized exchanges. Polo has issues it seems
-
the crux of the story is: do not use centralized exchanges. Polo has issues it seems
Yes I knew that and now learned harder way. But again maybe others don't.
Anyway, to be more specific this is what I have in mind when opening this thread:
First noticed - 28.05.2017 9:00h AM status Temporarily Disabled
Last checked- 28.05.2017 3:31h PM status Temporarily Disabled
-
This can cause unnecessary selling pressure of BTS on poloniex
-
This can cause unnecessary selling pressure of BTS on poloniex
Exactly!! That's why we need to track it.
to make this public. ALL IT TAKES FOR EVIL TO PROSPER IS FOR GOOD MEN TO DO NOTHING.
Anyway
Last checked- 28.05.2017 5:00h PM status Temporarily Disabled
P.S. I have BTS withdrawal request in pending since 2017-05-27 08:14:01
-
It still "Temporarily Disabled" >:(
-
Deposit and withdrawal finally enabled!!
Received withdrawal. It took 2days for withdrawal this time!
-
I wonder what caused this issue...
-
Hopefully a technical issue rather than a fractional reserve issue.
-
They're probably running their own node. I wouldn't be surprised if they ran into memory issues, as currently the needed memory scales up linearly with the total number of blocks. You currently need over 12GB of RAM. There's an issue about it here: https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-core/issues/192
-
They're probably running their own node. I wouldn't be surprised if they ran into memory issues, as currently the needed memory scales up linearly with the total number of blocks. You currently need over 12GB of RAM. There's an issue about it here: https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-core/issues/192
On a full node the memory requirement is now around 16GB, but why is that an issue? You can have servers with 516GB, and I am sure Poloniex can afford a server or 2 for BTS (if they set it up right, they should have a full node with a delayed node).
-
They're probably running their own node. I wouldn't be surprised if they ran into memory issues, as currently the needed memory scales up linearly with the total number of blocks. You currently need over 12GB of RAM. There's an issue about it here: https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-core/issues/192
On a full node the memory requirement is now around 16GB, but why is that an issue? You can have servers with 516GB, and I am sure Poloniex can afford a server or 2 for BTS (if they set it up right, they should have a full node with a delayed node).
You're right, it shouldn't be an issue, but it still could be one. They have 60+ wallets they need to maintain, and probably have them all sandboxed for security reasons. BTS might be the only wallet that have these high memory requirements, and yes they can afford it but they probably didn't start with that much memory. If the wallet daemon crashed, they may needed to re-index the whole blockchain again on a new server instance, which can take a long time.
I'm just speculating, as this happened to my node recently, and I had to deal with it.