Welp, now it worked.
Maybe I'll get a withdrawal code later today.
My tips from last week still haven't sent though so I guess I need to reissue them.
Update: ^ That looks like a mistake on my part. I left out the #.
Update 2 : I'm now wondering if the withdrawal code issue could be because I rage quit this forum account, then recreated it later? Perhaps I need to transfer everything from this account to another so I can withdraw. I will test this and see. hmmm
Update 3 : Confirmed. I cannot withdraw from the existing sharebits account because I nuked the forum account then recreated it. I'm going to guess it's tied to the userID # here on the forum and since I have a new one now, even though the name is the same, I will never receive the code to this "Tuck Fheman" account. I'll work around it.
So there is no issue with withdrawal codes.