What do you not understand about "Social Currency" tony?
Do people working in a guild and doing various organizational tasks for a token that only a few guild leaders can pass around for work done "Brown-Nose"? Or do they do valuable stuff for the organization?
This is what it comes down to. You can disagree with anything else...but one thing you can't be right about is that DKP (and likely other social currencies with similar attributes) WORKS. It has worked to build a huge network of gaming communities that spans across the entire web and all geographical locations that have the internet. So people can put this down as much as they want...but they are arguing against facts that can be EASILY researched by them...
Now tony, I am not trying to be an asshole here...but to be honest, I can see why you would hate a social currency, because if you made one you would have like 5 people who want it, and it would likely only get them into complaining sessions that go nowhere in the direction of an actual solution.
Done with this though because I have important stuff to do and this ridiculous drama is not one of them. :/