Thank you!!
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: toast on August 08, 2014, 11:07:44 PM
Hmm... I'm not sold on this.QuoteEssentially, I think it would be a mistake to allocate two or more TLDs and have the DAC sell one copy of each name under each TLD. First of all, it seems strange for the DAC to sell names under various "ICANN-compatible" TLDs even though the DAC does not own any of them.The DAC would not be selling any ICANN TLDs to begin with. Maybe I misunderstood?QuoteSecond, putting TLDs inside the blockchain creates a huge question mark around who will administer this list of "BitShares TLDs" --- basically begging the question of whether we need a TLD DAC to administer the list of TLDs in the DNS DAC...This is decided by the DAC's shareholders. Adding a new TLD requires a hard fork which requires shareholder approval through their delegates.QuoteThird, letting different parties buy the same name multiple times obviously implies an overall devaluation of all possible names sold by the DAC, especially considering that it may be possible to introduce an arbitrary number of even more TLDs at any time in the future.Not convinced by this, it seems to work fine for ICANN names. Adding new TLDs does not devalue anyone except for existing name holders. If you are holding only to speculate then I don't care if you are devalued. If your name is valuable because it is well known then you are not devalued by someone registering the same thing on a different TLD (e.g. money.org vs money.com).
I think we would get more revenue from new names being registered on new TLDs than we would from people paying extra because there is only one TLD to compete in. Look at how many ridiculous TLDs ICANN is milking.
I think it is a good thing that we leave ourselves the possibility to create different TLDs with different rules in the future. Slicing up the one true namespace in anticipation of what we think the "one better" and "one worse" models is painting ourselves into a corner.
The idea that some parameters can be set based on the name lengths is appealing, though. For example, for the ownership model, the fixed renewal rate can be set by length.
Page created in 0.144 seconds with 12 queries.