[POLL] Possible committee actions to help with liquidity

[fuzzy]

is there a way to get a list quickly of who has posted to a thread?

[Akado]

Thanks I edited the post to avoid confusion

[BunkerChainLabs-DataSecurityNode]

So where does this stand now? Any agreement reached?

Some fund will be get out from the accumulated fee pool and deposit to committee-account, after  8 hours. The amout is around 7000$.

No other agreement reached.

Oh sorry, I was searching on worker proposals and didn't find that's why I found it strange. @rgcrypto maybe a page showing both worker and committee proposals and a tab for each would be easier, it's confusing I need to scroll down and didn't know about it, no info regarding committee proposals on the nav bar.

@abit I believe the review period starts in 7 hours. So in 7 hours the funds won't be moved but voting will start?
http://cryptofresh.com/p/1.10.48

That proposal was not done right.. a new one was created afterwards.. which you can see has been supported:

http://cryptofresh.com/p/1.10.49

[Akado]

So where does this stand now? Any agreement reached?

Some fund will be get out from the accumulated fee pool and deposit to committee-account, after  8 hours. The amout is around 7000$.

No other agreement reached.

Oh sorry, I was searching on worker proposals and didn't find that's why I found it strange. @rgcrypto maybe a page showing both worker and committee proposals and a tab for each would be easier, it's confusing I need to scroll down and didn't know about it, no info regarding committee proposals on the nav bar.

@abit I believe the review period starts in 7 hours. So in 7 hours the funds won't be moved but voting will start?
http://cryptofresh.com/p/1.10.49

[fuzzy]

So where does this stand now? Any agreement reached?

Good questions akado.  Thanks to the committee for being open and helping answer questions. 

[abit]

So where does this stand now? Any agreement reached?

Some fund will be get out from the accumulated fee pool and deposit to committee-account, after  8 hours. The amout is around 7000$.

No other agreement reached.

[Akado]

So where does this stand now? Any agreement reached?

[puppies]

what I get is

Code: [Select]

unlocked >>> sign_builder_transaction 0 true
sign_builder_transaction 0 true
3468578ms th_a       wallet.cpp:1919               sign_transaction     ] Caught exception while broadcasting tx 9e1369d210581e5622950658aa75f791d226ac61:  0 exception: unspecified
10 assert_exception: Assert Exception
required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.
    {"provided":"1.2.1191","required":["1.2.0"]}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate

    {"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction
    {"error":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[\"1.2.0\"]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"id":187,"error":{"code":1,"message":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[\"1.2.0\"]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"code":10,"name":"assert_exception","message":"Assert Exception","stack":[{"context":{"level":"error","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":196,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.","data":{"provided":"1.2.1191","required":["1.2.0"]}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":199,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"evaluator.cpp","line":46,"method":"start_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":653,"method":"apply_operation","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":636,"method":"_apply_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":220,"method":"push_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}}]}}}}
    th_a  state.cpp:38 handle_reply
0 exception: unspecified
10 assert_exception: Assert Exception
required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.
    {"provided":"1.2.1191","required":["1.2.0"]}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate

    {"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction
    {"error":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[\"1.2.0\"]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"id":187,"error":{"code":1,"message":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[\"1.2.0\"]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":9305,\"ref_block_prefix\":2804019475,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T03:58:18\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}],[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":0,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":false,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"code":10,"name":"assert_exception","message":"Assert Exception","stack":[{"context":{"level":"error","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":196,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.","data":{"provided":"1.2.1191","required":["1.2.0"]}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":199,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"evaluator.cpp","line":46,"method":"start_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":653,"method":"apply_operation","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":636,"method":"_apply_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":220,"method":"push_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T03:57:48"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":9305,"ref_block_prefix":2804019475,"expiration":"2016-01-09T03:58:18","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}],[24,{"fee":{"amount":0,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":false,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["1f066d3b3cafac0b51a8dacc8a1abb347ed681d990ada29ae4430f88946f6f1391666615a46546877f0f18b1d439cd16392c6a8451d6768d8e6412efdd73fc895a"]}}}]}}}}
    th_a  state.cpp:38 handle_reply
unlocked >>>

when I try to use 1.2.0 as the authority it also fails.  Then it has

3030006 invalid_committee_approval: committee account cannot directly approve transaction
Committee account may only propose transactions

[abit]

Yeah.  I'm at dinner with the wife.  I'll post later.

I just tried by myself. 

Code: [Select]

{
  "ref_block_num": 8845,
  "ref_block_prefix": 4171956341,
  "expiration": "2016-01-09T03:35:18",
  "operations": [[
      24,{
        "fee": {
          "amount": 200000,
          "asset_id": "1.3.0"
        },
        "fee_paying_account": "1.2.12376",
        "using_owner_authority": false,
        "proposal": "1.10.48",
        "extensions": []
      }
    ]
  ],
  "extensions": [],
  "signatures": [
    "1f4b0fc547dcfd8629a3cfe520d6338ce231399af409abe3df538c97f91e915550391098eeeea075c922acad5dccd3a3c64fd4ebb0e3f26ed248ee9f728c23514
1"
  ]
}


Code: [Select]

10 assert_exception: Assert Exception
required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.
    {"provided":"1.2.12376","required":["1.2.0"]}

//Edit:
So it doesn't recursively check the authorities in case when multi-sig authority involved. A bug?
Imo it's better to set a threshold equals to (total_weight - approve_threshold) for proposal_delete_operation, so the proposal will only be deleted if enough authorities agree to delete the proposal.

//Edit2:
I submitted an issue to github: https://github.com/cryptonomex/graphene/issues/515

[puppies]

Yeah.  I'm at dinner with the wife.  I'll post later.

[abit]

I get the same error with the false flag on owner authority. 

Also anyone abusing the transaction would need to be voted out.

Can you post here the whole error message when the flag is false? I think it should be different at least this line:

Code: [Select]

{"provided":"1.2.1191","required":[]}


[puppies]

I get the same error with the false flag on owner authority. 

Also anyone abusing the transaction would need to be voted out.

[abit]

Hmm.. @puppies you may need to set "using_owner_authority" to false, as the committee-account has no owner authority but only active authority: http://cryptofresh.com/u/committee-account

committee-account 1.2.0
Owner none
Active Multisig Auth

A little off-topic: looks like this proposal_delete_operation isn't well designed. By this way a "bad" committee member is able to prevent anything from happening. Maybe some misunderstanding here..

This operation allows the early veto of a proposed transaction. It may be used by any account which is a required authority on the proposed transaction, when that account's holder feels the proposal is ill-advised and he decides he will never approve of it and wishes to put an end to all discussion of the issue.

[puppies]

Thanks again abit.

So I was playing a little bit trying to use the proposal_delete_operation.  I was doing this manually in the wallet.  I can create the builder.  add the operation.  Pay the correct fees.  When I sign with false flag I get

Code: [Select]

unlocked >>> sign_builder_transaction 2 false
sign_builder_transaction 2 false
{
  "ref_block_num": 6918,
  "ref_block_prefix": 722491212,
  "expiration": "2016-01-09T01:58:39",
  "operations": [[
      24,{
        "fee": {
          "amount": 200000,
          "asset_id": "1.3.0"
        },
        "fee_paying_account": "1.2.1191",
        "using_owner_authority": true,
        "proposal": "1.10.48",
        "extensions": []
      }
    ]
  ],
  "extensions": [],
  "signatures": [
    "2011ec79668c490caf27a8ce307c23ebaa26fd8170a53a33c2414c16db02486b38770b5131d8771d8a8dc5ca6c8d0cdec4361ec72af293cd4ed254abd442a37174"
  ]
}
unlocked >>>

But when I sign with true flag I get

Code: [Select]

unlocked >>> sign_builder_transaction 2 true
sign_builder_transaction 2 true
3554900ms th_a       wallet.cpp:1919               sign_transaction     ] Caught exception while broadcasting tx 07670ef5b21243f272b7c9b7c256380fcafa8ea8:  0 exception: unspecified
10 assert_exception: Assert Exception
required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.
    {"provided":"1.2.1191","required":[]}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate

    {"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction
    {"error":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"id":184,"error":{"code":1,"message":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"code":10,"name":"assert_exception","message":"Assert Exception","stack":[{"context":{"level":"error","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":196,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.","data":{"provided":"1.2.1191","required":[]}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":199,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"evaluator.cpp","line":46,"method":"start_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":653,"method":"apply_operation","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":636,"method":"_apply_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":220,"method":"push_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}}]}}}}
    th_a  state.cpp:38 handle_reply
0 exception: unspecified
10 assert_exception: Assert Exception
required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.
    {"provided":"1.2.1191","required":[]}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate

    {"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}
    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate

    {}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction

    {"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}
    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction
    {"error":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"id":184,"error":{"code":1,"message":"10 assert_exception: Assert Exception\nrequired_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.\n    {\"provided\":\"1.2.1191\",\"required\":[]}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:196 do_evaluate\n\n    {\"o\":{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}}\n    th_a  proposal_evaluator.cpp:199 do_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  evaluator.cpp:46 start_evaluate\n\n    {}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:653 apply_operation\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:636 _apply_transaction\n\n    {\"trx\":{\"ref_block_num\":6939,\"ref_block_prefix\":4113412531,\"expiration\":\"2016-01-09T01:59:42\",\"operations\":[[24,{\"fee\":{\"amount\":200000,\"asset_id\":\"1.3.0\"},\"fee_paying_account\":\"1.2.1191\",\"using_owner_authority\":true,\"proposal\":\"1.10.48\",\"extensions\":[]}]],\"extensions\":[],\"signatures\":[\"20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741\"]}}\n    th_a  db_block.cpp:220 push_transaction","data":{"code":10,"name":"assert_exception","message":"Assert Exception","stack":[{"context":{"level":"error","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":196,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"required_approvals->find(o.fee_paying_account) != required_approvals->end(): Provided authority is not authoritative for this proposal.","data":{"provided":"1.2.1191","required":[]}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"proposal_evaluator.cpp","line":199,"method":"do_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"o":{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"evaluator.cpp","line":46,"method":"start_evaluate","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":653,"method":"apply_operation","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":636,"method":"_apply_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}},{"context":{"level":"warn","file":"db_block.cpp","line":220,"method":"push_transaction","hostname":"","thread_name":"th_a","timestamp":"2016-01-09T01:59:14"},"format":"","data":{"trx":{"ref_block_num":6939,"ref_block_prefix":4113412531,"expiration":"2016-01-09T01:59:42","operations":[[24,{"fee":{"amount":200000,"asset_id":"1.3.0"},"fee_paying_account":"1.2.1191","using_owner_authority":true,"proposal":"1.10.48","extensions":[]}]],"extensions":[],"signatures":["20092147f99b4596202d2cafa54aa81e7a5330fb6adc5c7f3484f4e4f4b75e32132cc4bad1637d7a71a476feef30ac320418e0ff7e98cbf6750770d38257d06741"]}}}]}}}}
    th_a  state.cpp:38 handle_reply
unlocked >>>
[code]

I have tried changing a couple of the options within the transaction, still fails.  Any idea what I am doing wrong?


[abit]

Thanks abit.  Do you want to create the new proposal or would you prefer someone else do it?

Yes, I can do it.
So you prefer "expiration_time": "2016-01-18T23:59:59" still?

//Update:
Done.
http://cryptofresh.com/p/1.10.49

//Update 2:
Source code for proposing above proposal:
https://github.com/abitmore/python-graphenelib/blob/cb3539a2e5f8913e7bdb9c7d8b02228feffbaf75/scripts/witness-claim-accumulated-fees/main.py