Author Topic: Subsidizing Market Liquidity  (Read 79795 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1034
    • View Profile
Bump!

What do you think of performing manual UIA sharedrops against participants in fill orders for MPA on the BTS DEX?

I'm thinking of taking the list of an MPA's asset holders, then grabbing each of these user's trading history for the last month, then filter for fill orders & evaluate their market making participation for sharedrop issuance.. should we only be incentivizing fill orders or should we also consider incentivizing collateral?

Offline R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1034
    • View Profile
*bump*

Any thoughts regarding my BTS liquidity bot BOINC project idea?

Offline R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1034
    • View Profile
https://steemit.com/gridcoin/@cm-steem/brainstorming-new-boinc-projects-anyone-can-create-a-project-and-reward-their-users-with-gridcoin#@cm-steem/re-cm-steem-brainstorming-new-boinc-projects-anyone-can-create-a-project-and-reward-their-users-with-gridcoin-20160812t153824382z

Thoughts? The major difficulty would be providing the liquidity software to volunteers without providing said volunteers the ability to steal funds from the liquidity software. If this difficult issue was solved, then we could easily distribute liquidity software to several thousand individuals from all around the world.

If a BOINC project was created for this purpose, you could go a step further and distribute UIA against those running the liquidity software: https://steemit.com/steem/@cm-steem/gauging-interest-would-you-be-interested-being-able-to-tip-boinc-users-your-crypto-asset-of-choice
« Last Edit: August 12, 2016, 03:48:13 pm by crypto123 »

Offline bitsharesbrazil

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 243
    • View Profile
very important topic for dex n smartcoins future, our main product.......i need reread everything carefully this is for pros!
bitcointalk ANN https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1084460.0
chat, post, promote it!!!!!!!! Stan help to improve OP!

Offline CoinHoarder

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 660
  • In Cryptocoins I Trust
    • View Profile
 +5% +5%

What is happening with this? Bitshares really needs this or something like it.

I still think my idea is better, but something is better than nothing. Last time I discussed my idea with forum members, I was never convinced that it wouldn't work. The main antagonists mainly slapped their knees and said "Nubits = bad". However, they wrongly deduced that my idea is anything like Nubits... because it isn't. It is quite different from Nubits in numerous ways. For instance, Nubits' recent derailing of their peg would not of happened with my proposal.

1.   Bitshares autonomously issues new BTS tokens, specifically for the purpose of funding liquidity operations.
2.   Bitshares shorts every committee-issued SmartCoin, and puts them up for sale at an arbitrary percentage over the price feed, while at the same time putting up buy orders at the same arbitrary percentage below the peg. Autonomous liquidity is provided for both sides of the markets.
3.   The percentage the SmartCoins are sold over (and under) the price feed, the amount of liquidity provided for each SmartCoin market and the amount of collateral is determined by the committee. Thus, it can be adjusted whenever the community deems it is necessary.
4.   Considering that the autonomous liquidity is provided at an arbitrary amount above (and below) the peg, Bitshares will make a profit each time these autonomous liquidity operations are utilized. Thus, the amount of funds available for these liquidity operations will grow in time without the need for any more dilution. This profit can be used to provide more liquidity, or it can be burned as the community sees fit.
5.   If the liquidity pool for any certain SmartCoin is running low, Bitshares can autonomously issue more BTS tokens so that the amount of liquidity provided (which is again set by the committee) is maintained.
     a.   This step would only be necessary if:
              i.   The committee adds more SmartCoins (such as bitAPPLE, bitGOOGLE, etc.) to the DEX.
             ii.   On the off chance that the market making operations are unprofitable due to market trends. Market making operations cannot be guaranteed to be profitable.
6.   Instant liquidity is observed across all SmartCoin markets, effectively bootstrapping DEX liquidity and fixing one of Bitshares’ most glaring problems.
7.   As “natural liquidity” (liquidity provided by actual users) grows, the committee can lower the amount of liquidity provided autonomously. Effectively, this proposal works as training wheels on a bicycle. As soon as the DEX has sufficient “natural liquidity”, all autonomous liquidity operations can cease and the BTS/SmartCoins that were printed can be burned.
     a.   Autonomous liquidity operations can be ceased on a market-by-market basis, as inherently some markets will be dynamically more liquid than others.
« Last Edit: June 21, 2016, 05:13:04 pm by CoinHoarder »
https://www.decentralized.tech/ -> Market Data, Portfolios, Information, Links, Reviews, Forums, Blogs, Etc.
https://www.cryptohun.ch/ -> Tradable Blockchain Asset PvP Card Game

Offline abit

  • Committee member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4664
    • View Profile
    • Abit's Hive Blog
  • BitShares: abit
  • GitHub: abitmore
@abit:

Was just wondering, how can the spread be negative?
Negative spread means someone was selling smart coins below the feed price.

Nice data reports.  Are you able to put them up in a site with visual charts? 
Hope someone else would do that. I'm not willing to run web services, however I can provide data feeds, like this https://data.sparkfun.com/bitshares_usd_price
BitShares committee member: abit
BitShares witness: in.abit

Offline cube

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1404
  • Bit by bit, we will get there!
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: bitcube
Nice data reports.  Are you able to put them up in a site with visual charts? 


Update: @kenCode @onceuponatime @BunkerChain Labs more liquidity statistics data of BTS/CAD is below. If you want data of other markets please let me know.
Code: [Select]
2016-04-17 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1679784630.0000,          86400,                 220.0729,           1.85%, indominon
  413342520.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           1.29%, disperse
  147415772.1936,          86400,                 160.9778,          11.60%, hcf27
   89943323.4054,          54282,                  16.8783,           1.05%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   40433650.1589,          86400,                  20.4515,           9.45%, altfund
   11114188.2180,          10269,                   8.9795,           0.83%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
2016-04-18 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1716062835.0000,          86400,                 281.7237,           2.14%, indominon
  196092009.7368,          86400,                 184.9540,          11.31%, hcf27
  186564821.5332,          86400,                  40.0080,           2.09%, disperse
   24619179.3372,          86400,                  20.4515,          10.19%, altfund
    9467900.5362,          50544,                   1.2515,           0.51%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
2016-04-19 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1876070530.3704,          86400,                 251.6304,           1.48%, indominon
  327427800.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           1.16%, disperse
  270215003.6730,          69948,                  26.9448,           0.56%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  247900736.8764,          86400,                 195.4876,          10.66%, hcf27
  182062500.0000,          17631,                  50.0000,          -0.07%, onceuponatime
   94502025.0000,          17877,                  25.0000,          -0.12%, marginal
   33160397.5437,          86400,                  20.4515,           9.33%, altfund
2016-04-20 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  851181600.0000,          86400,                 215.0000,           3.22%, indominon
  392471850.0000,          86400,                  71.6423,           2.85%, onceuponatime
  295600137.1692,          79035,                  32.4233,           0.98%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  214231200.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           2.64%, disperse
  202722788.7825,          86400,                  36.3281,           2.82%, marginal
  198717551.7468,          86400,                 186.2514,          11.50%, hcf27
   26128035.2127,          86271,                  20.3121,          10.58%, altfund
    1234775.1276,           1578,                  13.6062,           1.80%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-21 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  574943245.5240,          86400,                 199.2234,           4.10%, onceuponatime
  469674601.8288,          82737,                  38.9014,           0.56%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  254933228.8119,          86400,                  90.3350,           4.25%, marginal
  233829915.0000,          74811,                 214.2290,           6.69%, indominon
  103236600.5508,          86400,                 149.0214,          13.06%, hcf27
   44048520.0000,          69180,                  40.0000,           6.14%, disperse
   35459123.5656,          46281,                  14.4396,           1.99%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   17263562.5431,          86148,                  16.8216,          10.76%, altfund
2016-04-22 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1438698942.8346,          86400,                 137.1420,           0.98%, onceuponatime
  617953808.4951,          86151,                  51.6665,           0.63%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  365934445.8084,          86400,                 140.3869,           8.32%, hcf27
   51993996.1632,          12216,                  25.1806,           0.32%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   36136899.0792,           2322,                  58.2390,          -0.67%, marginal
   21372200.1354,          86271,                  15.7902,           9.76%, altfund
2016-04-23 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1697320301.7438,          86400,                  92.0367,           0.19%, hcf27
 1694801465.7336,          86400,                  91.6481,          -0.02%, onceuponatime
 1034187019.0377,          86400,                  55.2286,           0.02%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   26186324.7135,          86400,                  17.4020,          10.46%, altfund
2016-04-24 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1654176620.6574,          76896,                 100.0262,          -0.11%, hcf27
 1463269701.0723,          76896,                  54.0614,          -1.52%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
 1358711400.0000,          76896,                  50.0000,          -1.53%, onceuponatime
   39200607.8700,          86400,                  17.0829,           8.62%, altfund
    3748584.4500,           7746,                   2.0363,          -0.38%, unosuke
    1254069.3837,           6534,                   3.9529,           2.10%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-25 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   58358130.9186,          85635,                  29.8558,           8.86%, altfund
   33496939.0944,          68835,                   2.0364,          -0.36%, unosuke
    2019105.1008,           8787,                   3.9538,           1.86%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-26 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  177149031.6762,          27948,                  45.7554,           0.64%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   24185387.2896,          86367,                   5.4528,           2.03%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   17363588.3697,          86271,                  18.4351,          11.48%, altfund
2016-04-27 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  595482875.4582,          85974,                  45.7554,           0.51%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   29916689.3946,          86313,                   5.5512,           1.71%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   20071257.4335,          86271,                  20.3897,          11.10%, altfund
2016-04-28 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  947452356.5940,          86019,                  73.2746,           0.50%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   40690830.5124,          86400,                  20.3897,           9.09%, altfund
   34111728.8160,          86346,                   7.6565,           2.02%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   19728352.3809,           3399,                  23.6251,          -0.46%, disperse
2016-04-29 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2227947988.1724,          86400,                  75.2492,          -1.43%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  117411998.7360,          86400,                   7.6565,           0.30%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   52077420.8892,          86271,                  20.3897,           8.77%, altfund
2016-04-30 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1222946762.6844,          86400,                  75.2492,           0.11%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   44017945.8675,          86400,                   7.6565,           1.82%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   21683841.2499,          86400,                  20.3897,          11.02%, altfund
Code: [Select]
2016-05-01 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  572562734.8896,          86400,                  75.2492,           1.72%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   29011690.7916,          86397,                   7.9288,           3.11%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   16678450.0854,          86400,                  20.3897,          12.45%, altfund
2016-05-02 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  175282627.0104,          86400,                  75.2492,           4.81%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   11202146.2938,          86400,                  17.4858,          14.24%, altfund
    8893063.2807,          32901,                   2.5635,           0.95%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-05-03 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  123107615.9508,          86400,                  75.2492,           5.22%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   11644654.5285,          86400,                  20.0003,          15.47%, altfund
2016-05-04 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  137606707.0560,          86400,                  75.2492,           4.68%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   12106146.6996,          86400,                  20.3721,          15.08%, altfund
2016-05-05 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  434611673.3328,          86364,                  87.4432,           2.69%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   12377701.5975,          86400,                  20.3897,          14.79%, altfund
    2680374.8628,          39576,                   1.0716,           1.85%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-06 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1305533288.5548,          86238,                  99.7111,           0.60%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   15784473.5538,          78615,                  21.0222,          12.95%, altfund
   11363508.3222,          86400,                   1.9318,           1.94%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-07 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1266293439.2160,          86025,                  95.2144,           0.45%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   62093345.9601,          85851,                   6.5323,           0.89%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   26731017.3057,          86400,                  21.4923,          10.55%, altfund
   15740399.8626,          86373,                   1.6074,           0.86%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-08 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1214654861.5200,          86034,                  95.2144,           0.52%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   58143120.4395,          86379,                   6.5323,           0.97%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   36772847.0229,          86178,                  21.9355,           9.72%, altfund
   22366630.0599,          86385,                   2.9839,           1.22%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-09 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2102588296.1949,          86091,                  96.1060,          -0.53%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   61752279.4416,          86400,                  21.4711,           8.88%, altfund
   32259025.4001,          45147,                   6.5323,           0.92%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   10077515.1780,          52350,                   2.9795,           2.06%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-10 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2337113349.8355,          86400,                  53.9059,          -3.02%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   60140709.1824,          86400,                  17.3626,           5.51%, altfund
   42730700.3604,          53103,                   5.2372,           0.46%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-05-11 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  414175344.1707,          53049,                  13.6305,          -3.73%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   88822292.5095,          86400,                   5.7235,           0.19%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   43268387.5026,          86391,                  32.6149,           9.09%, altfund
ID: bitcube
bitcube is a dedicated witness and committe member. Please vote for bitcube.

Offline tbone

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 632
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: tbone2
@abit:

Was just wondering, how can the spread be negative?

Offline abit

  • Committee member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4664
    • View Profile
    • Abit's Hive Blog
  • BitShares: abit
  • GitHub: abitmore
Update: @kenCode @onceuponatime @BunkerChain Labs more liquidity statistics data of BTS/CAD is below. If you want data of other markets please let me know.
Code: [Select]
2016-04-17 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1679784630.0000,          86400,                 220.0729,           1.85%, indominon
  413342520.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           1.29%, disperse
  147415772.1936,          86400,                 160.9778,          11.60%, hcf27
   89943323.4054,          54282,                  16.8783,           1.05%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   40433650.1589,          86400,                  20.4515,           9.45%, altfund
   11114188.2180,          10269,                   8.9795,           0.83%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
2016-04-18 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1716062835.0000,          86400,                 281.7237,           2.14%, indominon
  196092009.7368,          86400,                 184.9540,          11.31%, hcf27
  186564821.5332,          86400,                  40.0080,           2.09%, disperse
   24619179.3372,          86400,                  20.4515,          10.19%, altfund
    9467900.5362,          50544,                   1.2515,           0.51%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
2016-04-19 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1876070530.3704,          86400,                 251.6304,           1.48%, indominon
  327427800.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           1.16%, disperse
  270215003.6730,          69948,                  26.9448,           0.56%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  247900736.8764,          86400,                 195.4876,          10.66%, hcf27
  182062500.0000,          17631,                  50.0000,          -0.07%, onceuponatime
   94502025.0000,          17877,                  25.0000,          -0.12%, marginal
   33160397.5437,          86400,                  20.4515,           9.33%, altfund
2016-04-20 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  851181600.0000,          86400,                 215.0000,           3.22%, indominon
  392471850.0000,          86400,                  71.6423,           2.85%, onceuponatime
  295600137.1692,          79035,                  32.4233,           0.98%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  214231200.0000,          86400,                  40.0000,           2.64%, disperse
  202722788.7825,          86400,                  36.3281,           2.82%, marginal
  198717551.7468,          86400,                 186.2514,          11.50%, hcf27
   26128035.2127,          86271,                  20.3121,          10.58%, altfund
    1234775.1276,           1578,                  13.6062,           1.80%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-21 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  574943245.5240,          86400,                 199.2234,           4.10%, onceuponatime
  469674601.8288,          82737,                  38.9014,           0.56%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  254933228.8119,          86400,                  90.3350,           4.25%, marginal
  233829915.0000,          74811,                 214.2290,           6.69%, indominon
  103236600.5508,          86400,                 149.0214,          13.06%, hcf27
   44048520.0000,          69180,                  40.0000,           6.14%, disperse
   35459123.5656,          46281,                  14.4396,           1.99%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   17263562.5431,          86148,                  16.8216,          10.76%, altfund
2016-04-22 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1438698942.8346,          86400,                 137.1420,           0.98%, onceuponatime
  617953808.4951,          86151,                  51.6665,           0.63%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  365934445.8084,          86400,                 140.3869,           8.32%, hcf27
   51993996.1632,          12216,                  25.1806,           0.32%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   36136899.0792,           2322,                  58.2390,          -0.67%, marginal
   21372200.1354,          86271,                  15.7902,           9.76%, altfund
2016-04-23 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1697320301.7438,          86400,                  92.0367,           0.19%, hcf27
 1694801465.7336,          86400,                  91.6481,          -0.02%, onceuponatime
 1034187019.0377,          86400,                  55.2286,           0.02%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   26186324.7135,          86400,                  17.4020,          10.46%, altfund
2016-04-24 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1654176620.6574,          76896,                 100.0262,          -0.11%, hcf27
 1463269701.0723,          76896,                  54.0614,          -1.52%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
 1358711400.0000,          76896,                  50.0000,          -1.53%, onceuponatime
   39200607.8700,          86400,                  17.0829,           8.62%, altfund
    3748584.4500,           7746,                   2.0363,          -0.38%, unosuke
    1254069.3837,           6534,                   3.9529,           2.10%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-25 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   58358130.9186,          85635,                  29.8558,           8.86%, altfund
   33496939.0944,          68835,                   2.0364,          -0.36%, unosuke
    2019105.1008,           8787,                   3.9538,           1.86%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-26 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  177149031.6762,          27948,                  45.7554,           0.64%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   24185387.2896,          86367,                   5.4528,           2.03%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   17363588.3697,          86271,                  18.4351,          11.48%, altfund
2016-04-27 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  595482875.4582,          85974,                  45.7554,           0.51%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   29916689.3946,          86313,                   5.5512,           1.71%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   20071257.4335,          86271,                  20.3897,          11.10%, altfund
2016-04-28 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  947452356.5940,          86019,                  73.2746,           0.50%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   40690830.5124,          86400,                  20.3897,           9.09%, altfund
   34111728.8160,          86346,                   7.6565,           2.02%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   19728352.3809,           3399,                  23.6251,          -0.46%, disperse
2016-04-29 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2227947988.1724,          86400,                  75.2492,          -1.43%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  117411998.7360,          86400,                   7.6565,           0.30%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   52077420.8892,          86271,                  20.3897,           8.77%, altfund
2016-04-30 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1222946762.6844,          86400,                  75.2492,           0.11%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   44017945.8675,          86400,                   7.6565,           1.82%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   21683841.2499,          86400,                  20.3897,          11.02%, altfund
Code: [Select]
2016-05-01 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  572562734.8896,          86400,                  75.2492,           1.72%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   29011690.7916,          86397,                   7.9288,           3.11%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   16678450.0854,          86400,                  20.3897,          12.45%, altfund
2016-05-02 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  175282627.0104,          86400,                  75.2492,           4.81%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   11202146.2938,          86400,                  17.4858,          14.24%, altfund
    8893063.2807,          32901,                   2.5635,           0.95%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-05-03 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  123107615.9508,          86400,                  75.2492,           5.22%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   11644654.5285,          86400,                  20.0003,          15.47%, altfund
2016-05-04 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  137606707.0560,          86400,                  75.2492,           4.68%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   12106146.6996,          86400,                  20.3721,          15.08%, altfund
2016-05-05 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  434611673.3328,          86364,                  87.4432,           2.69%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   12377701.5975,          86400,                  20.3897,          14.79%, altfund
    2680374.8628,          39576,                   1.0716,           1.85%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-06 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1305533288.5548,          86238,                  99.7111,           0.60%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   15784473.5538,          78615,                  21.0222,          12.95%, altfund
   11363508.3222,          86400,                   1.9318,           1.94%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-07 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1266293439.2160,          86025,                  95.2144,           0.45%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   62093345.9601,          85851,                   6.5323,           0.89%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   26731017.3057,          86400,                  21.4923,          10.55%, altfund
   15740399.8626,          86373,                   1.6074,           0.86%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-08 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1214654861.5200,          86034,                  95.2144,           0.52%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   58143120.4395,          86379,                   6.5323,           0.97%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   36772847.0229,          86178,                  21.9355,           9.72%, altfund
   22366630.0599,          86385,                   2.9839,           1.22%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-09 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2102588296.1949,          86091,                  96.1060,          -0.53%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   61752279.4416,          86400,                  21.4711,           8.88%, altfund
   32259025.4001,          45147,                   6.5323,           0.92%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   10077515.1780,          52350,                   2.9795,           2.06%, liquidity-bot-mauritso4
2016-05-10 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 2337113349.8355,          86400,                  53.9059,          -3.02%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   60140709.1824,          86400,                  17.3626,           5.51%, altfund
   42730700.3604,          53103,                   5.2372,           0.46%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-05-11 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  414175344.1707,          53049,                  13.6305,          -3.73%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   88822292.5095,          86400,                   5.7235,           0.19%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   43268387.5026,          86391,                  32.6149,           9.09%, altfund
BitShares committee member: abit
BitShares witness: in.abit

Offline kenCode

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2283
    • View Profile
    • Agorise
kenCode - Decentraliser @ Agorise
Matrix/Keybase/Hive/Commun/Github: @Agorise
www.PalmPay.chat

Offline abit

  • Committee member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4664
    • View Profile
    • Abit's Hive Blog
  • BitShares: abit
  • GitHub: abitmore
@kenCode @onceuponatime BTS/CAD scores are here.
Formula used to calculate score in this link : https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php/topic,21544.msg289590.html#msg289590
Code: [Select]
2016-04-01 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2016-04-02 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  479730450.0000,          75603,                  50.0000,           0.89%, marginal
2016-04-03 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  376408700.1840,          86400,                  49.9989,           1.42%, marginal
2016-04-04 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  157197578.5920,          86400,                  49.9792,           4.25%, marginal
2016-04-05 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   66762847.3536,          86400,                  49.9265,           6.29%, marginal
         19.5120,             21,                   0.0248,           2.65%, liquidity-bot-xdfx6
2016-04-06 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   70602916.6782,          62619,                  58.9682,           5.27%, marginal
    9344869.5435,          42153,                  19.9497,          10.73%, altfund
     313690.8300,           3711,                   7.9000,          10.59%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
         96.3855,          18432,                   0.0005,          11.36%, liquidity-bot-xdfx6
2016-04-07 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  287759760.0000,          86400,                 120.0000,           3.67%, marginal
   18844195.8423,          86400,                  19.8560,          10.08%, altfund
    9718461.1755,          52269,                  11.1444,           9.46%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
    7857066.6600,          86355,                   7.8996,          10.09%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
     116049.5820,           4929,                   2.1399,          10.13%, liquidity-bot-gold21
2016-04-08 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1222919640.0000,          63990,                  97.1261,           0.27%, marginal
  172131468.2187,          85929,                  70.3872,           5.36%, altfund
   44390792.0427,          86382,                  10.7678,           6.85%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   13834891.5900,          86400,                   7.5612,           7.74%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    2024773.7103,          58575,                   2.1465,           9.15%, liquidity-bot-gold21
    1104040.0947,          13902,                   5.9915,          10.14%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
     631157.7822,          26493,                   2.1401,          10.16%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-09 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  433448895.0000,          73371,                  38.2023,           0.46%, marginal
  193185544.8228,          86271,                  89.1701,           6.92%, altfund
   18432836.2542,          86379,                  10.5874,           9.14%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   11575350.0000,          12825,                  75.8947,          10.27%, hcf27
    8951356.4904,          86352,                   7.3768,           9.35%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    7746293.5170,          86352,                   5.9752,          10.04%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
    5352933.1215,          34470,                   7.4134,           9.18%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    2418480.0441,          86364,                   2.1396,           9.91%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-10 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  235020829.5204,          74718,                  66.4142,           8.44%, hcf27
  152601980.1036,          28224,                  17.7114,          -0.86%, marginal
  112264922.4327,          86139,                  68.4092,          10.08%, altfund
   36276140.8602,          86379,                   9.2921,           7.92%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   29190766.0914,          86376,                   6.7895,           7.84%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   26815035.2262,          86376,                   7.5069,           8.77%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
   17212301.8422,          86352,                   6.3059,           9.81%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   12882037.6500,          10728,                  14.4860,           1.39%, unosuke
    7411279.1298,          86364,                   1.7573,           7.88%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-11 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  226429327.8402,          86400,                  74.0978,           7.46%, altfund
  128306580.0000,          33678,                  20.0000,           0.11%, marginal
   91981309.7982,          33651,                  14.9171,           0.20%, unosuke
   24950477.4021,          86400,                   7.6895,           6.90%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   20819216.8554,          86376,                   5.8730,           7.42%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   16257712.0380,          86373,                   7.8505,           9.12%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    9492898.0689,          86331,                   6.5211,           9.68%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
    3348479.0349,          86373,                   1.5270,           8.61%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-12 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  399054944.4963,          86400,                  66.7580,           4.49%, altfund
   76486235.2398,          86172,                  10.5278,           3.22%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   55305467.2596,          86310,                   8.9203,           5.20%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   22898510.0523,          55479,                   7.0434,           5.05%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   18307597.6302,          63702,                   8.0667,           8.08%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    2704948.8942,          86400,                   1.5597,           8.63%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-13 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  327604995.6066,          83652,                  25.8160,           0.49%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  174148048.8558,          84324,                  19.7136,           0.99%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
  150599909.6640,          78348,                  40.4333,           2.33%, marginal
   56750351.1588,          50739,                  55.1550,           6.00%, altfund
     661879.8651,          34983,                   1.5169,           9.58%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-14 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  573780169.6980,          86265,                  51.0970,           0.70%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  259198640.7666,          86100,                  30.1531,           1.04%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
  142314300.0000,           7860,                 100.0000,           0.18%, indominon
  129195313.9890,          86400,                  40.4470,           2.76%, marginal
   49382325.0000,          38388,                  99.9648,          10.32%, hcf27
   16876810.6155,          36876,                  39.9558,          11.18%, altfund
2016-04-15 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  947160585.0000,          61686,                  96.1387,           0.42%, indominon
  399864325.5210,          56157,                  51.0970,           0.65%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  231069070.9911,          82806,                  24.5363,           0.89%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
  181145163.0270,          64998,                  41.7463,           2.21%, marginal
   94376925.0000,          86400,                  91.6939,          10.76%, hcf27
   26953932.9072,          56331,                  39.9041,          11.07%, altfund
2016-04-16 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(CAD),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1944614835.0000,          78777,                 234.7345,           1.32%, indominon
  160461523.1514,          86400,                 166.4073,          11.31%, hcf27
   54096240.0000,           6450,                  40.0000,          -0.09%, disperse
   28312325.2809,          83421,                   3.1825,           1.00%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   17482373.7570,          31056,                  25.2144,          10.14%, altfund
BitShares committee member: abit
BitShares witness: in.abit

Offline abit

  • Committee member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4664
    • View Profile
    • Abit's Hive Blog
  • BitShares: abit
  • GitHub: abitmore
Updated scores and related data in EUR/BTS market:
Code: [Select]
2016-04-01 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  250503237.4629,          82617,                 305.3737,           9.58%, bts-scotter
   27221079.6000,          86400,                  41.8000,          12.46%, liondani
   15580021.5384,          86400,                  18.2666,           9.67%, altfund
    1266542.7588,          48576,                   2.5707,           9.45%, inarizushi
2016-04-02 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  283152877.3458,          86400,                 305.3737,           9.01%, bts-scotter
   28497024.6000,          86400,                  41.8000,          11.93%, liondani
   16613545.7664,          86400,                  18.2666,           9.13%, altfund
2016-04-03 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  275702980.5606,          86400,                 305.3737,           9.15%, bts-scotter
   28311683.4000,          86400,                  41.8000,          12.08%, liondani
   24672346.9869,          84732,                  28.9513,          10.00%, altfund
     321518.3616,          17766,                   1.0707,           5.73%, antman890
2016-04-04 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  228594201.3564,          86400,                 305.3737,          11.38%, bts-scotter
   62036456.5413,          86400,                  89.4922,          13.06%, altfund
   23930959.8000,          86400,                  41.8000,          14.23%, liondani
    1217967.2901,          86400,                   1.0707,           7.92%, antman890
2016-04-05 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  194139802.9065,          86400,                 305.3737,          12.81%, bts-scotter
   52144072.1850,          86400,                  89.4922,          14.46%, altfund
   21599146.8000,          86400,                  41.8000,          15.61%, liondani
     945507.3318,          86400,                   1.0707,           9.41%, antman890
2016-04-06 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  204159419.3772,          86400,                 305.3737,          12.20%, bts-scotter
   53689303.3404,          86274,                  74.6011,          12.70%, altfund
   22085322.6000,          86400,                  41.8000,          15.02%, liondani
    1019154.3606,          86400,                   1.0707,           8.77%, antman890
     647557.2120,            165,                  13.6030,          -0.88%, mf-tzo
     223506.2250,           3720,                   5.3172,          10.16%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
2016-04-07 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  228067431.7239,          86400,                 305.3737,          11.02%, bts-scotter
   91298250.0000,          51399,                 250.0000,          13.43%, hugogoulart
   64178934.8070,          86400,                  59.0192,           9.49%, altfund
   24261388.8000,          86400,                  41.8000,          13.88%, liondani
    5664953.6586,          52272,                   7.2767,           9.15%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
    5378275.7307,          86358,                   5.2537,           9.85%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    1030284.2871,          77091,                   1.0707,           7.82%, antman890
     348001.2387,           9396,                   1.2819,           3.41%, hcf27
      74945.3340,           4986,                   1.4176,          10.45%, liquidity-bot-gold21
2016-04-08 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  402232130.1660,          86400,                 305.3737,           6.78%, bts-scotter
  216266250.0000,          86400,                 250.0000,           9.74%, hugogoulart
  113177815.4358,          85911,                  49.4321,           8.17%, altfund
   36026166.0000,          86400,                  41.8000,           9.78%, liondani
   18505503.4875,          86382,                   6.8498,           7.46%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
   14579342.0448,          86400,                   1.1626,           1.31%, hcf27
    9433227.9429,          86400,                   5.0587,           8.66%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    1256984.7966,          58737,                   1.4220,           9.54%, liquidity-bot-gold21
     820598.4297,           9780,                   6.5913,           9.72%, gold-mine
     631812.8628,          13905,                   4.0378,          10.90%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
     548911.6506,          27564,                   1.8700,          10.40%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-09 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  516839795.8971,          86400,                 305.3737,           5.22%, bts-scotter
  254116500.0000,          86400,                 250.0000,           8.23%, hugogoulart
   46036964.3199,          86268,                  39.0550,          10.74%, altfund
   42258169.8000,          86400,                  41.8000,           8.27%, liondani
    8893063.7451,          86382,                   7.1191,          10.10%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
    7583349.3258,          86358,                   5.0584,           8.91%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    6019348.3032,          86400,                   3.7423,           5.59%, hcf27
    5872279.0644,          86355,                   4.0645,          10.05%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
    5126273.1861,          34512,                   5.0796,           8.34%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    1843986.2718,          86400,                   1.9250,          10.35%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-10 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  641074500.0000,          40932,                 250.0000,           6.17%, hugogoulart
  307256636.3463,          77805,                 261.7285,           7.47%, bts-scotter
  105651130.2000,          40932,                  41.8000,           6.21%, liondani
   98901551.4495,          40932,                  24.7161,           4.55%, hcf27
   60203082.8904,          86142,                  48.9843,          11.24%, altfund
    9153766.9794,          81756,                   4.2575,           9.67%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    8539407.2832,          51045,                   6.3794,           9.98%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
    7128896.5920,          81825,                   3.3514,          10.13%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
    6013054.6734,          52911,                   4.4974,          10.10%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    2609749.4892,          22080,                   0.8181,           0.91%, lin9uxis
    2256716.3844,          41688,                   1.8667,           8.57%, liquidity-bot-bm
2016-04-11 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  203062435.9842,          86364,                 243.8607,          11.80%, bts-scotter
   63045259.2621,          86400,                  47.8009,           9.71%, altfund
   28664143.6950,          73029,                  17.7294,           6.74%, lin9uxis
   10421922.3498,          86400,                   2.7953,           7.02%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
    5889780.8652,          86379,                   2.2405,           8.13%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    5057244.0000,          23136,                  12.0000,           5.31%, mf-tzo
    4649968.5468,          86379,                   3.5671,          10.44%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    4043822.3133,          86340,                   2.6223,          10.34%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
2016-04-12 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  184400378.7000,          74262,                  59.8885,           2.71%, lin9uxis
  158725194.2100,          86400,                 264.4230,          13.38%, bts-scotter
   48644049.8322,          86400,                  87.5899,          15.58%, altfund
   37088100.0000,          74418,                  12.0000,           2.69%, mf-tzo
   14851206.9189,          75273,                   3.0389,           5.94%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
   13052533.0683,          82977,                   2.1416,           4.14%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
    3235363.3944,          63702,                   3.2218,           9.41%, liquidity-bot-linouxis2
    1367414.0955,          55479,                   1.4165,           7.43%, liquidity-bot-mauritso2
2016-04-13 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  183696659.8428,          84627,                  14.7424,           0.53%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  113107835.0706,          60057,                  98.7177,          16.29%, altfund
   76662915.9213,          86007,                   8.3629,           0.97%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   32650952.0400,          20580,                 264.4230,          15.18%, bts-scotter
2016-04-14 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  175152253.2675,          86274,                  13.1509,           0.51%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
  145550405.9097,          86121,                  16.2243,           1.07%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   13981905.1650,          36879,                  27.6572,          10.56%, altfund
2016-04-15 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  133207487.4483,          76944,                  17.1908,           1.00%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
   23654215.1253,          56328,                  27.6005,          10.20%, altfund
    2526552.0000,           9996,                  36.0000,          13.04%, liondani
    2261559.6990,           3384,                   2.4555,          -0.72%, liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
    1573635.0000,           6393,                  35.0000,          12.88%, lin9uxis
2016-04-16 score,  shown seconds,  average order size(EUR),  average spread, account
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   14676118.5792,          44838,                   2.2240,           0.53%, unicef
   10054002.5571,          39303,                  30.6234,          11.32%, liondani
    8992500.0000,          17985,                 100.0000,          19.64%, mf-tzo
    4197606.8352,          29196,                  12.3309,           9.70%, altfund
     816358.4748,           4944,                  16.7016,           9.63%, lin9uxis
     348007.9845,          56082,                   0.0430,           0.60%, liquidity-bot-mauritso
       3566.5392,            537,                   0.8302,          11.60%, sir-richard
@kenCode
BitShares committee member: abit
BitShares witness: in.abit

Offline tbone

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 632
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: tbone2
BTS/bitEUR score (formula is here https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php/topic,21544.msg289590.html#msg289590)
Code: [Select]
2016-04-13
 183696659.8428,liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
 113107835.0706,altfund
  76662915.9213,liquidity-bot-mauritso
  32650952.0400,bts-scotter

Nice work, @abit!  The only comment I have is that we previously discussed rewarding balance between buy and sell side orders.  So for example if a market makers scores 3000 on the bid side and 2000 on the ask side, they would get full credit for 2000 + 2000.  And then we could apply some factor less than 1 to the remaining 1000 from the bid side score.   I don't think the factor should be 0, but perhaps in the .25-.5 range.  In the future we can do something more sophisticated that identifies the weak and strong sides of a market when it's trending, that way we can more heavily reward liquidity provided to the weak side.   

By the way, can you test out your scoring on a UIA?  Maybe OBITS since it's one of the most active?  Thanks for your work on this, @abit!
Thanks! Scoring of UIA pairs is on my to-do list.

According to https://cryptofresh.com/assets, in last 24 hours, the most active UIA:UIA pair is MKR:OPEN.BTC, the most active BTS pair is BTS:OPEN.BTC

UIA related pairs need to add some factors to the formula, I haven't figured out the final formula.

Doesn't really matter which UIA to test on as long as it has some good volume.  But I did ask Ronny several days ago on another thread if he would be interested in using this and he said yes.  I have no idea if @Rune would use it.  Although I don't see why not!

Anyway, what about the point I brought up about taking into account balance between buy and sell side liquidity?  Actually, I think it would be best for your script to simply produce 2 scores (one for the buy side, one for the sell side) and leave it at that.  Then the issuer can apply their own "balance factor", which would be a very simple calculation that can be done in a spreadsheet.  The issuer will already have to make some decisions about how to use the scoring data to begin with.  For example, do they want to have a minimum score for a MM to qualify for a rewards?  Do they want to reward only the top X number of MMs in a given period?  Do they want to reward only those MMs who provided a minimum % of the total liquidity?  Etc.  This will all have to be up to the issuer, and they may try different things.
I'll bring out more statistics data, E.G. average spread per account, average volume, total show up time/duration, then the issuers will have a clearer picture.

Buy and sell side will be calculated independently.

Some of the decisions you mentioned require modifications to the formula itself, fortunately it's not hard to change atm. To be more productive, it's best that the issuers come out and say what they want.

Actually, none of the scoring methods I mentioned require further pre-processing.  But if any issuers can think of a way they would like to score that DOES require additional pre-processing, I agree now is a good time for them to speak up.  Otherwise I think we'll pretty much be all set once you break out the bid and ask sides.  On second thought, another thing I just remembered - I still think it's a good idea to add bid_ask_midpoint as a top level field next to price_feed.

Offline abit

  • Committee member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4664
    • View Profile
    • Abit's Hive Blog
  • BitShares: abit
  • GitHub: abitmore
BTS/bitEUR score (formula is here https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php/topic,21544.msg289590.html#msg289590)
Code: [Select]
2016-04-13
 183696659.8428,liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
 113107835.0706,altfund
  76662915.9213,liquidity-bot-mauritso
  32650952.0400,bts-scotter

Nice work, @abit!  The only comment I have is that we previously discussed rewarding balance between buy and sell side orders.  So for example if a market makers scores 3000 on the bid side and 2000 on the ask side, they would get full credit for 2000 + 2000.  And then we could apply some factor less than 1 to the remaining 1000 from the bid side score.   I don't think the factor should be 0, but perhaps in the .25-.5 range.  In the future we can do something more sophisticated that identifies the weak and strong sides of a market when it's trending, that way we can more heavily reward liquidity provided to the weak side.   

By the way, can you test out your scoring on a UIA?  Maybe OBITS since it's one of the most active?  Thanks for your work on this, @abit!
Thanks! Scoring of UIA pairs is on my to-do list.

According to https://cryptofresh.com/assets, in last 24 hours, the most active UIA:UIA pair is MKR:OPEN.BTC, the most active BTS pair is BTS:OPEN.BTC

UIA related pairs need to add some factors to the formula, I haven't figured out the final formula.

Doesn't really matter which UIA to test on as long as it has some good volume.  But I did ask Ronny several days ago on another thread if he would be interested in using this and he said yes.  I have no idea if @Rune would use it.  Although I don't see why not!

Anyway, what about the point I brought up about taking into account balance between buy and sell side liquidity?  Actually, I think it would be best for your script to simply produce 2 scores (one for the buy side, one for the sell side) and leave it at that.  Then the issuer can apply their own "balance factor", which would be a very simple calculation that can be done in a spreadsheet.  The issuer will already have to make some decisions about how to use the scoring data to begin with.  For example, do they want to have a minimum score for a MM to qualify for a rewards?  Do they want to reward only the top X number of MMs in a given period?  Do they want to reward only those MMs who provided a minimum % of the total liquidity?  Etc.  This will all have to be up to the issuer, and they may try different things.
I'll bring out more statistics data, E.G. average spread per account, average volume, total show up time/duration, then the issuers will have a clearer picture.

Buy and sell side will be calculated independently.

Some of the decisions you mentioned require modifications to the formula itself, fortunately it's not hard to change atm. To be more productive, it's best that the issuers come out and say what they want.
BitShares committee member: abit
BitShares witness: in.abit

Offline tbone

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 632
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: tbone2
BTS/bitEUR score (formula is here https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php/topic,21544.msg289590.html#msg289590)
Code: [Select]
2016-04-13
 183696659.8428,liquidity-bot-linouxisbot
 113107835.0706,altfund
  76662915.9213,liquidity-bot-mauritso
  32650952.0400,bts-scotter

Nice work, @abit!  The only comment I have is that we previously discussed rewarding balance between buy and sell side orders.  So for example if a market makers scores 3000 on the bid side and 2000 on the ask side, they would get full credit for 2000 + 2000.  And then we could apply some factor less than 1 to the remaining 1000 from the bid side score.   I don't think the factor should be 0, but perhaps in the .25-.5 range.  In the future we can do something more sophisticated that identifies the weak and strong sides of a market when it's trending, that way we can more heavily reward liquidity provided to the weak side.   

By the way, can you test out your scoring on a UIA?  Maybe OBITS since it's one of the most active?  Thanks for your work on this, @abit!
Thanks! Scoring of UIA pairs is on my to-do list.

According to https://cryptofresh.com/assets, in last 24 hours, the most active UIA:UIA pair is MKR:OPEN.BTC, the most active BTS pair is BTS:OPEN.BTC

UIA related pairs need to add some factors to the formula, I haven't figured out the final formula.

Doesn't really matter which UIA to test on as long as it has some good volume.  But I did ask Ronny several days ago on another thread if he would be interested in using this and he said yes.  I have no idea if @Rune would use it.  Although I don't see why not!

Anyway, what about the point I brought up about taking into account balance between buy and sell side liquidity?  Actually, I think it would be best for your script to simply produce 2 scores (one for the buy side, one for the sell side) and leave it at that.  Then the issuer can apply their own "balance factor", which would be a very simple calculation that can be done in a spreadsheet.  The issuer will already have to make some decisions about how to use the scoring data to begin with.  For example, do they want to have a minimum score for a MM to qualify for a rewards?  Do they want to reward only the top X number of MMs in a given period?  Do they want to reward only those MMs who provided a minimum % of the total liquidity?  Etc.  This will all have to be up to the issuer, and they may try different things.