Author Topic: Cn-vote's statement on version 4.0 Upgrade -- to all witne公会关于4.0版本升级的声明——致所有见证人  (Read 8192 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline pluswave

见证人可以分为4类:

1. 所有出块节点打了cn-vote补丁。
2. 所有出块节点没打cn-vote补丁。
3. 有些打了补丁,有些没打。活跃的出块节点打了补丁。
4. 有些打了补丁,有些没打。活跃的出块节点没打补丁。

分叉时间(北京时间8月20日晚上9:55),
A. 如果所有活跃的见证人处于1和3,那么区块链将有一次协议升级;
B. 如果所有活跃的见证人处于2和4,那么什么都不会发生;
C. 如果50%处于1和3, 那么?
C. 如果80%处于1和3, 那么?
E. 如果80%处于2和4, 那么?

但是API节点并没有升级,如果区处于A,那么所有没打补丁的API节点将会挂掉。

以上英文版本在这里:

English translation of above paragraphs is here.
https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-core/issues/2239#issuecomment-674463527

希望各个见证人声明自己的序号,尤其是3和4,区别很大。 出于网络稳定性考虑,magicwallet.witness 将变成第4类。
blog: https://blog.xiaofuxing.name
org: https://www.magicwallet.io
Please vote for magicwallet.witness !

Offline zhouxiaobao

带为发布:见证人biz  marvell-witness 将运行打补丁的链。

Offline liondani

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3737
  • Inch by inch, play by play
    • View Profile
    • My detailed info
  • BitShares: liondani
  • GitHub: liondani
liondani witness will not install the cn-vote's patch.

Online Bhuz

  • Committee member
  • Sr. Member
  • *
  • Posts: 466
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: bhuz
I am not sure to understand the point of this patch...

I would understand it if it was a total reversal of the latest voting rules/changes, but from what I saw and from other analyses, it is not. Most of the "concerning" changes are still there, so I don't really see the point in setting up a second node to support that fork.

There is still time to set it up, so if anyone would like to enlighten me, I could change my mind.

As for now, my main witness node and API server will not run the patch.

Online Thul3

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 570
    • View Profile
I am not sure to understand the point of this patch...

I would understand it if it was a total reversal of the latest voting rules/changes, but from what I saw and from other analyses, it is not. Most of the "concerning" changes are still there, so I don't really see the point in setting up a second node to support that fork.

There is still time to set it up, so if anyone would like to enlighten me, I could change my mind.

As for now, my main witness node and API server will not run the patch.

You do nothing diffrent than on steem where witnesses hijacked steem which many proxies where against.
There you had at least the support of the community.
Here you have no support.

You installed knowingly malcious code and were silent about it.You did it with full intention.You broke once again rules and protocol as witness.

CN-Vote is not going to fork out of bitshares.
We have the majority of votes and also majority of community behind us even in foreign community.

Anyone supporting malcious code of Abit with the poor explanation it is the legit one won't receive votes from majority of proxies anymore.

You did wrong and want to force as a small minority the majority to accept your point of view by creating fud and fear.
The next attempt to disable witness voting because you couldn't even receive enough support when changing in a hidden agenda shows clearly what bad actors you are who doesn't care about consent at all.
Wasn't it you personly on telegram chat who asked cn-vote for supporting you as witness with the explanation you will always follow consensus based on voting ?
Seems your words are worth nothing.

We don't accept it and i will be very clear i see no bigger proxy supporting it other than beos,bitcrab,abit.

And if you don't understand the patch i recommend reading the forum.There is an explanation from me and cn-vote that reversal of code needs more work so the easiest way was to change parameters only to not change compatibility.

Quote
liondani witness will not install the cn-vote's patch.

Could you please tell what infra you provided as witness other than a VPS and where you activly where participating in bitshares ?
Cause in committee you glanced with total  absence over the last 1 1/2 years

You were also one of the known steem witnesses who fucked up ?
« Last Edit: August 17, 2020, 08:20:19 pm by Thul3 »

Offline zapata42

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 62
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: zapata42
I don't support the patch nor the fork:

  • The patch is not properly tested (no unit test, no testnet)
  • the content is not a reversal as announced, but a new unspecified behaviour;
  • from my understanding of the code it does not remove most of the controversial behaviours like non voting rights for bts in collateral or in orders;
  • the fork not properly prepared is not good for Bitshares as it is untested, feeds are not ready, exchanges and gateway supports are not properly defined, liquidity will be reduced.

Online Thul3

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 570
    • View Profile
I don't support the patch nor the fork:

  • The patch is not properly tested (no unit test, no testnet)
  • the content is not a reversal as announced, but a new unspecified behaviour;
  • from my understanding of the code it does not remove most of the controversial behaviours like non voting rights for bts in collateral or in orders;
  • the fork not properly prepared is not good for Bitshares as it is untested, feeds are not ready, exchanges and gateway supports are not properly defined, liquidity will be reduced.

There will be an update about the points you posted from cn-vote

Online Bhuz

  • Committee member
  • Sr. Member
  • *
  • Posts: 466
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: bhuz
You installed knowingly malcious code and were silent about it.You did it with full intention.You broke once again rules and protocol as witness.

I have no idea what you smoked, but I urge you to stop because it seems to hurt you and makes you think you are omniscient.

You did wrong and want to force as a small minority the majority to accept your point of view by creating fud and fear.

You are the one creating fud and spreading bullshit here. Stop claiming or even speculating about me being aware of the latest addition to the 4.0 release. I was not aware of any changes in voting rules, so stop bullshitting around.


Wasn't it you personly on telegram chat who asked cn-vote for supporting you as witness with the explanation you will always follow consensus based on voting ?

cn-vote is the same group that kicked me out exactly because I was following the consensus.

If there is really consensus then active witnesses will be changed to reflect community will. I encourage that.
If a fork is going to happen that's exactly because there is a split in consensus (so no real homogeneous consensus).


And if you don't understand the patch i recommend reading the forum.There is an explanation from me and cn-vote that reversal of code needs more work so the easiest way was to change parameters only to not change compatibility.

"Not change compatibility" ?
...Applying that patch will create a fork... what other "compatibility" are you trying to preserve? It doesn't make sense.

As a witness I also have to evaluate the risk in running a certain version of the software, and as already stressed, that patch was not tested, it introduce new unspecified behaviour and above all it doesn't reverse the controversial changes that required the patch itself...it will also cause dangerous situations for the current BitShares ecosystem.

I invite you, cn-vote, and everyone that feels a come back is needed, to take the necessary time and make it right instead of rushing it so badly.

Offline zapata42

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 62
    • View Profile
  • BitShares: zapata42
There will be an update about the points you posted from cn-vote

Good. I am in favor of a patch done correctly, as I don't support what Abit did. I just don't want to make the situation worse than it is already.

Online Thul3

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 570
    • View Profile
You installed knowingly malcious code and were silent about it.You did it with full intention.You broke once again rules and protocol as witness.

I have no idea what you smoked, but I urge you to stop because it seems to hurt you and makes you think you are omniscient.

You did wrong and want to force as a small minority the majority to accept your point of view by creating fud and fear.

You are the one creating fud and spreading bullshit here. Stop claiming or even speculating about me being aware of the latest addition to the 4.0 release. I was not aware of any changes in voting rules, so stop bullshitting around.


Wasn't it you personly on telegram chat who asked cn-vote for supporting you as witness with the explanation you will always follow consensus based on voting ?

cn-vote is the same group that kicked me out exactly because I was following the consensus.

If there is really consensus then active witnesses will be changed to reflect community will. I encourage that.
If a fork is going to happen that's exactly because there is a split in consensus (so no real homogeneous consensus).


And if you don't understand the patch i recommend reading the forum.There is an explanation from me and cn-vote that reversal of code needs more work so the easiest way was to change parameters only to not change compatibility.

"Not change compatibility" ?
...Applying that patch will create a fork... what other "compatibility" are you trying to preserve? It doesn't make sense.

As a witness I also have to evaluate the risk in running a certain version of the software, and as already stressed, that patch was not tested, it introduce new unspecified behaviour and above all it doesn't reverse the controversial changes that required the patch itself...it will also cause dangerous situations for the current BitShares ecosystem.

I invite you, cn-vote, and everyone that feels a come back is needed, to take the necessary time and make it right instead of rushing it so badly.

You use DL words.Are you guys chatting a lot ?
Quote
think you are omniscient
Am asking because to CN-Vote and Me you were basicly silent when asked about your opinion.

Quote
cn-vote is the same group that kicked me out exactly because I was following the consensus.
Actually it was Abit and another chinese who got you kicked out with the help of CN-Votes VP at that time.

Quote
If there is really consensus then active witnesses will be changed to reflect community will. I encourage that.
There is consensus who hold majority of vote power even after the malcious upgrade.

Quote
If a fork is going to happen that's exactly because there is a split in consensus (so no real homogeneous consensus).
CN-Vote and other proxies who are on their side do not want a fork and won't fork out of bitshares.Thats very clear.Anything else is FUD.
However we won't accept Abit's and DL's dictatorship anymore.There everyone agrees on.

Quote
As a witness I also have to evaluate the risk in running a certain version of the software, and as already stressed, that patch was not tested, it introduce new unspecified behaviour and above all it doesn't reverse the controversial changes that required the patch itself...it will also cause dangerous situations for the current BitShares ecosystem.

I invite you, cn-vote, and everyone that feels a come back is needed, to take the necessary time and make it right instead of rushing it so badly.

Would be good to have these concern posted as witness way before and trying to find with us a soltion.

@zapata42

We do it the right way.
I guess cn-vote is still translating.

There will be no risky situation for bitshares created




Offline liondani

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3737
  • Inch by inch, play by play
    • View Profile
    • My detailed info
  • BitShares: liondani
  • GitHub: liondani

Quote
liondani witness will not install the cn-vote's patch.

Could you please tell what infra you provided as witness other than a VPS and where you activly where participating in bitshares ?
Cause in committee you glanced with total  absence over the last 1 1/2 years

You were also one of the known steem witnesses who fucked up ?

You are known to the community for spreading lies and FUD. You are mixing your lies with some good point's every now and then and occasionally you present some facts. This comment is one more proof that you are a liar in general.

1. I provide a dedicated Hetzner server for my witness liondani (i7-7700 @3600 Mhz, 4cores, 64GB
    RAM, 500 GB NVME)
2. Backup dedicated server has the same specs (actually I am switching from one to another on
    updates)
3. Contabo VPS server for a) price feeds and b) running the bitshares monitor script
4. Hetzner dedicated server for the api node api-bts.liondani.com (32GB RAM, 500 GB SSD, i7-
    7700 @3600Mhz, 8 cores)
5. Test-net vps node from contabo running liondani-test (place #9)
6.  Seed node server for hard-coded (default seed nodes for BTS) seed01.liondani.com 1776 
     (Xeon E5-2630 @2.20GHz, 8 cores, 32 GB RAM, 800 GB HDD)


PS  Can you enlighten me about the steem fuck up?  (LOL)
« Last Edit: August 18, 2020, 07:40:07 am by liondani »

Offline EuropaSH

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 260
  • IT innovations
    • View Profile
    • https://xbts.io
  • BitShares: euro888
公会关于4.0版本升级的声明——致所有见证人
众所周知,在BTS4.0版本升级中,个别开发人员在社区不知情的情况下,私自篡改投票系统,造成极其恶劣的影响。我们认为,这种行为践踏了BTS区块链的信任基础、撕裂了社区团结、动摇了投资者的持币信心。如果不立即纠正,BTS在区块链世界中将再无信用可言。

为此,公会开发了4.0版本补丁程序,该补丁程序目的是将投票系统恢复成4.0版本之前的状态,以消除不良影响。该补丁仅修复了未经社区投票私自增加的变更,不影响4.0版本其他功能的正常使用。

我们呼吁所有见证人安装该补丁。见证人安装该补丁文件后,该补丁文件将在北京时间2020年8月20日21:55分自动生效。

请所有见证人(包括非活跃见证人)在北京时间2020年8月15日24:00分之前在本帖下回复补丁安装情况。从北京时间2020年8月16日开始,我们将对没有回复安装补丁文件的见证人撤票,并投票给已经安装补丁文件的见证人。若支持安装补丁文件的见证人数量不足,公会将启用公会备用见证人,将见证人数量补足。

其他所有个人节点、交易所节点、重钱包也应当在20日之后安装此补丁,以免影响使用。

公会将不断致力于维护BTS区块链系统的信用、公平和正义,我们支持一切合法的、有益的系统升级。

如见证人安装补丁时有任何问题请联系微信:xiaoyuan  409

补丁下载地址:https://github.com/bitshares-cnvote/bitshares-core



Cn-vote's statement on version 4.0 Upgrade -- to all witnesses
As we all know, in the bts4.0 version upgrade, individual developers tamper with the voting system without the knowledge of the community, causing extremely bad impact. We believe that this behavior has trampled on the trust foundation of BTS blockchain, torn community unity and shaken investors' confidence in currency holding. If not corrected immediately, BTS will no longer have credibility in the blockchain world.

To this end, CN vote developed a 4.0 patch, which aims to restore the voting system to the state before version 4.0 to eliminate adverse effects.This patch only fixes the changes that are added without community voting, and does not affect the normal use of other functions of version 4.0.

We call on all witnesses to install the patch. After the witness installs the patch, the patch will automatically take effect at 21:55, August 20, 2020(Beijing time).

All witnesses (including inactive witnesses) are requested to reply to the patch installation under this post before 24:00 Beijing time on August 15, 2020. Starting from August 16, 2020, Beijing time, we will withdraw votes for witnesses who have not responded to the installation of patch files and vote for witnesses who have installed patch files. If the number of witnesses supporting the installation of patch files is insufficient, CN vote will enable the standby witness to supplement the number of witnesses.

The cn-vote will continue to be committed to maintaining the credit, fairness and justice of BTS blockchain system. We support all legal and beneficial system upgrades.

If the witness has any problems in installing the patch, please contact wechat:
 Xiaoyuan  409

Patch download address:  https://github.com/bitshares-cnvote/bitshares-core

The information provided below is available on the association's website:

China BitShares Association cn-vote Governance Rules

The cn-vote guild is a democratic organization spontaneously formed by the retail investors of BitShares. It is a gathering place for retail pool, so that everyone's voice in the guild can be heard. This is the original intention of the guild. The purpose of the guild is to do everything for the benefit of BitShares and all the guild's retail investors, not to let the big players, the air force to harvest, even if the pool is small, it has power. We will not allow all proposals that are not conducive to the interests of the Association's retail investors to pass, and initiate nominations for proposals that are beneficial to the interests of the Association.

http://btsgh.com/?p=27

中国比特股公会cn-vote治理规则

cn-vote 公会是比特股散户自发形成的一个民主组织,是一个散户韭菜集结地,让公会 每个人的声音被听到,是公会建立的初衷。公会宗旨是一切为了比特股,一切为了公会散户 的利益,不任由大户,空军收割,韭菜虽小,也有力量。不任由不利于公会散户利益的各项 提案议案通过,发起提名利于公会利益的各项提案议案。



On August 17, the association voted by all members. Due to the failure of the negotiation, the announcement decided to activate the 4.0 upgrade patch at 21:55 pm on September 10.

http://btsgh.com/?p=218

8月17日,公会经过全体成员投票,因协商失败,公告决定于9月10号晚21:55分激活4.0升级补丁。


Will it be a new patch? the patch you posted is dated August 20
XBTS DEX EXCHANGE FOR TRADERS AND GAMERS https://xbts.io

Offline binggo

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2241
    • View Profile
Quote
Will it be a new patch? the patch you posted is dated August 20

I guess they have different date ...

Online Thul3

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 570
    • View Profile
Quote
You are known to the community for spreading lies and FUD.

You mean known for it at BEOS,CL and Abit when posting staff they don't like.
Isn't Stan now attacking so many members who accuse him the same as i do calling them with diffrent names ?


Sorry i don't have much time since i'm currently on business travel and prefer to focus now my limited personal time on positive things which will bring bitshares forward.
It is witness decission which way they go but don't expect people to follow your decission if they don't like it.Trying to force them is even worse and gets a bigger response.


Have a nice day


Quote
I guess they have different date ...

Correct ,so it can be done correctly




Offline EuropaSH

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 260
  • IT innovations
    • View Profile
    • https://xbts.io
  • BitShares: euro888
Quote
Will it be a new patch? the patch you posted is dated August 20

I guess they have different date ...

The witnesses who supported and installed the CN-Vote patch on the main nodes installed the patch dated August 20th:

Ioex https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343369#msg343369

Baidu https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343393#msg343393

Earth-moon https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343395#msg343395

Bangzi https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343478#msg343478

Clone https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343443#msg343443

K-witness https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343445#msg343445

Gdex-witness https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343455#msg343455

Delegate.freedom https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343462#msg343462

Delegate-zhaomu https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343477#msg343477

Education https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343485#msg343485

blckchnd  https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343496#msg343496

Biz https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343515#msg343515

Marvell-witness https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343515#msg343515


The nodes of the selected witnesses with CN-vote patch will be updated on August 20.

Or they need to update the main nodes again with a patch that goes into effect on September 10th.

However, we and the community and investors do not know how this will affect the network.




Witnesses who did not install the СN-Vote patch:

Xbtsio-wallet https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343405#msg343405

Magicwallet.witness https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343406#msg343406

Xn-delegate https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343410#msg343410

Liondani https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343544#msg343544

Bhuz https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343574#msg343574

Zapata42 https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=32560.msg343582#msg343582
XBTS DEX EXCHANGE FOR TRADERS AND GAMERS https://xbts.io