1
General Discussion / What happens to Rate Limited Free Transactions?!?!
« on: April 25, 2016, 03:31:32 am »
Everyone was so exited when BM announced that he have an idea for solving problem with fees. I have prepared a quick recap what happens when:
On Feb 5 @bytemaster during hangout described whole idea starting with words: "Could we imagine a scenario where the blockchain had no fees, at all?"
On Feb 8 @-banano- created a topic Will this community be surpporting BM's "zero fee" proposal to get micropayment? where 74 (93.7%) forum members agreed that this is a good idea.
On Feb 10 @bytemaster posted on his blog: How to build a Decentralized Application without Fees
On Feb 14 @abit created post: Rate Limited Free Transactions Feature Implemented
On March 1 @abit created a ticket #603 on cryptonomex/graphene github - Implement simple rate limited free transaction feature.
On March 8 @abit created a Pull Request #612 - "Implement rate limited free transactions feature #603"
On March 2 @abit first time (according to my knowledge) mentioned in comment of #603: "We need a BSIP document for this feature."
What happen next?
Today is April 25.
Rate Limited Free Transactions are still not a part of bitshares.
Some time ago I asked on dev slack of graphene:
This feature stucked somewhere and it seems that right now no one is finalizing a work on that.
I created this blog post in good faith, that this will help us:
- describe what is needed to finish that job (what are the blocker? Missing BSIP? Testing? Code Review? Something else?)
- develop a plan (with described steps) how to do that
- prepare a schedule for those steps with deadlines
We have to do something with that. I have a feeling that most of work is already done. It would be stupid and totally ineffective to abandon that work and this idea right now.
On Feb 5 @bytemaster during hangout described whole idea starting with words: "Could we imagine a scenario where the blockchain had no fees, at all?"
On Feb 8 @-banano- created a topic Will this community be surpporting BM's "zero fee" proposal to get micropayment? where 74 (93.7%) forum members agreed that this is a good idea.
On Feb 10 @bytemaster posted on his blog: How to build a Decentralized Application without Fees
On Feb 14 @abit created post: Rate Limited Free Transactions Feature Implemented
On March 1 @abit created a ticket #603 on cryptonomex/graphene github - Implement simple rate limited free transaction feature.
On March 8 @abit created a Pull Request #612 - "Implement rate limited free transactions feature #603"
On March 2 @abit first time (according to my knowledge) mentioned in comment of #603: "We need a BSIP document for this feature."
What happen next?
Today is April 25.
Rate Limited Free Transactions are still not a part of bitshares.
Some time ago I asked on dev slack of graphene:
This feature stucked somewhere and it seems that right now no one is finalizing a work on that.
I created this blog post in good faith, that this will help us:
- describe what is needed to finish that job (what are the blocker? Missing BSIP? Testing? Code Review? Something else?)
- develop a plan (with described steps) how to do that
- prepare a schedule for those steps with deadlines
We have to do something with that. I have a feeling that most of work is already done. It would be stupid and totally ineffective to abandon that work and this idea right now.